However Rohan has a bit more time to prepare and call for help. Gandalf, having snuck in and out of Mordor before knows about back routes as well as the dangers.
There would also not be an invasion on Saruman's keep by the Ents. I thought that was part of the reason Frodo left on his own, so that the others wouldn't be ruined by the rings corruption. Gollum tries to find his ring so he can become invisible and kill Bilbo. He was a liar and a theif before ever finding it. Now, the Fellowship, still relatively unscathed, though obviously exhausted from what is still quite a long journey stop at Lothlorien to resupply, this is where they meet back up with Gandalf who fills them in about Sauruman and the Uruk-Hai. And then at the moment of tossing the Ring into the fire, what's to say Frodo doesn't snap? Thus, the ring might have influenced Frodo more and he would have become Saurons minion sooner or later during the voyage.

Bilbo's decision not to kill Gollum, and his newfound courage.

GradeSaver provides access to 1492 study Within a month or so he's gathered reinforcements from the Elves and Dwarves to Minas Tirith as well as the retreating remnants of Rohan; even the Ents, who could feel the balance of power shifting in the world make an appearance. Reading Assignment, Questions, Vocabulary, Tolkien's Hobbit: From Children's Story to Mythic Creation, Sting and Bilbo: Significance of the Small in The Hobbit, Archetypes of Englishness in The Hobbit and Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland. The likelyhood that Eowyn was killed during the fall of Rohan means that the Witchking and the rest of the RingWraiths are able to influence the battle unopposed. Press J to jump to the feed. What will happen in this case? These papers were written primarily by students and provide critical analysis of The Hobbit by J.R.R. This is where I disagree. Even if Saruman doesn't have his urgency I think he'd still be at Helm's Deep. I can't think of anything wrong with your assessment. After that, the rest would be much the same. But it also has to do with Bilbo's nature. I'm of the opinion that in this revised timeline he doesn't.. or at the very least hasn't yet. Bilbo pities Gollum, and perhaps even empathizes with him - and sees that he can get out alive without harming the poor creature. Legolas and Gimli return to whereever they return to, all is right in the world. this is what makes Bilbo special he doesnt kill Gollum Ring that Bilbo gains,  this is what makes Bilbo special (he doesn’t kill Gollum), Ring that Bilbo gains helps transform him into the hero by the end of the, novel (he needs the ring to gain that status), We don’t get a discussion about the negative ramifications of the ring in, Other contest is the one between Bilbo and Smaug, We’re told a lot about Smaug before we actually meet him – makes him scarier, We discover that Smaug is proud, cunning, loquacious, and it’s dangerous to, We also get riddles with Smaug – these riddles recap the narrative  exposition =, characters give you a summary of the plot (in this case, Smaug and Bilbo’s, conversation recaps the narrative for the reader), Makes use of riddle style and syntax in order to give us recap of, All Bilbo’s boasts trigger our memory about what has happened. The most likely course of travel is by boat down the Anduin, or at the very least follow the Anduin on foot/horseback. Simple as that. You need to submit each of your questions one at a time. Even Frodo, who was partially resistant to the power of the Ring, ultimately could not bear to see it destroyed. this premium content, “Members Only” section of the site! c. he feels sorry for Gollum. Frodo/Gandalf might have had to kill Bilbo to get the ring and Frodo would have been tainted by evil. It's like Ask Science, but for all universes other than our own. He is a good-hearted soul and not inclined toward evil. (3-4 minutes) As a protagonist, Bilbo often prefers to take a non-violent approach. Sam and Frodo return to the Shire. Gollum Gollum is a slimy creature Bilbo encounters in the tunnels in the mountain inhabited by the goblins. At this point Gandalf is able to guide and conceal the party to Mount Doom since the whole country has been emptied for the strike at Minas Tirith. Years later, Gollum then went on to help both Frodo Baggins and Samwise Gamgee in their quest to destroy the ring, before turning on them and, ultimately, perishing along with the ring. We have tutors online 24/7 who can help you get unstuck. And indeed all Free Peoples must survive to aid the final defence against Sauron's forces. Saruman would be freed of Sauron's control, but would still be driven mad by it and would flee with his Army back to Isengard. After this, I think the Journey would have been relatively similar as even if Sauron doesn't know they are actively trying to destroy the Ring, the original plan is still the best. Certainly after the episode with Denethor and Boromir.

The longer you have the Ring, the more lasting its effects. Bilbo doesn't kill Gollum when he has the chance because... a. he thinks he might need him later on. It was pity that stayed Bilbo’s hand. Likely this is done before Minas Tirith has completely fallen, however that's not nessesarily true. Stuck? Not affiliated with Harvard College.

He would not be powerful enough to remove Sarumon's curse on Theodin. The orcs of mordor would flee, along with most likely the remaining Southrons. The only issue i have is that i don't think that Minas Tirith would hold. Or if Sam is turned by the Ring as well in a bit of a twist and Frodo's suspicions were not unfounded then the ending could just be a bit more tragic with both falling into the fire fighting over the Ring, perhaps forced by Eru like with Gollum. So he becomes invisible and follows Gollum out … I'm no Tolkien scholar and a lot of this is conjecture, speculation and top-of-the-head interpretation. But hey, we have the potential tragedy of Mount Doom to make up for it, right? Some that die deserve life. You're forgetting that Gandalf would not have fallen to the Balrog and therefore would still be "the Grey". And I don't see Aragorn abandoning the city once he's accepted kingship over it, so I don't see him surviving either. Would they try to rescue him? Gandalf is not going to let Rohan fall. Now, the trip to Rivendell would have been much more... pleasant than the run for their lives that it was. What magic powers does the ring give bilbo. However he did have the feeling that the Ring belonged in Gondor well before Moria, so I suspect it will come up again later. Gandalf also thinks Bilbo is courageous and heroic. Learn more about The Hobbit with Course Hero's FREE study guides and Why doesn't Bilbo kill Gollum? The fact of the matter is he simply will. Either way Gandalf knows about the Uruk-Hai and thus their plans must be put into motion. They where only called to action by the trickery of Merry/Pippin. I suppose the issue here is getting there. Each generation of great evil and second-in-command is less potent than the previous. And then I wonder why Aragorn won't approach the Dunharrow. Aragorn starts to call in every favour and browbeat every nation within reach to send soldiers to Gondor. He also would have been unlikely to send Aragorn to escort/protect the Hobbits. Many that live deserve death. I'm sure even with this spin Eomer has still been banished and even given the extra days to mount a defence his riders are in exile and news will reach them very slowly.

So they come over the Misty Mountains much farther to the north. Why exactly would Helm's Deep fall under this interpretation? If Bilbo had killed Gollum, he might have been corrupted more and had never given up the ring. guide PDFs and quizzes, 10461 literature essays, The party encounters some resistance, certainly, but is able to enter Mount Doom and destroy the Ring. Kind of a neat parallel, though.

6.Would Bilbo try to rescue the dwarves if they were still inside the Mountains? Bilbo, of course, being the luckiest person in the world, just happens to put on Gollum's ring right as Gollum comes to attack him. Since they have to go past it anyways to get to Mordor they rush to warn Rohan of Saruman's plan. Under this scenario, Gandalf doesn't discover Saruman's treachery before the council in Rivendell, so wouldn't Saruman have participated?

But the Ring's evil purposes in finding a new owner were taken by Iluvatar and turned to its despite:

Gandalf would probably have stayed with them rather than go off hunting the Ringwraiths. I'm not really sure if Rohan will fall. However this time I think that things go a little differently. This feels like a much darker and more phyrric victory - Sauron is still destroyed, sure, but the only real power left standing int he end is Saruman. This would have alerted to Nazgul to their presence and would also have lead to unrest in the Fellowship and to much more deceit/violence. Apparently, based on previous advice from Gandalf the Grey, Bilbo stayed his hand and let Gollum live. The process would have been much easier to achieve because Sauron would have had much harder time finding the Ring. Do not be too eager to deal out death in judgment. forgive me, it's been a while since I read the books, the finer details might escape me. Although I suppose if Gandalf predicts this he would try to remedy the situation as best he can. Would it have simply taken longer? Though he doesn't shy away from killing spiders (as you'll see in a later chapter! But the game makes Gollum both hungry and angry. Gollum didn't leave the Ring, the Ring left Gollum. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Looking back in on the Fellowship, they are now moving down the Anduin, in wild lands so it's not exactly an easy trip, unless they take a boat. Without antagonism from Gollum Frodo could naturally begin suspecting Sam or any one of his compatriots of desiring the Ring. Can you give it to them, Frodo? The Hobbit essays are academic essays for citation. as a child, figure (he wouldn’t become our stand-in for a child anymore). When the eagles rescue the travelers... a. Bilbo and the dwarves become their prisoners.
Being also regarded as a more powerful wizard of Gandalf, I would think it more likely that he would lead the Fellowship, and thereby gain the ring for himself. I like to think they can hold out until Gandalf and Frodo can destroy the Ring as I don't think they would leave it to the last minute. He would have taken Frodo, and probably Sam to Rivendell to council with Elrond. By the end, the city would have fallen, its populace fleeing or dead, but in doing so would have given time for the ring to be destroyed. This however turns out badly for Rohan in the long run as over the course of the rest of the story, behind the scenes so to speak, they fight a delaying war against an impossibly huge army eventually falling back to Helms Deep. resource to ask questions, find answers, and discuss the novel. Though he doesn't shy away from killing spiders (as you'll see in a later chapter! Since the original battle of Pellinor fields is won mostly through the help of the ghosts of Dunharrow, this battle will be much, much more difficult. He'd play his hand some how. Do you consider this lying? Tolkien, literature essays, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full summary and analysis. this is what makes Bilbo special (he doesn’t kill Gollum) Ring that Bilbo gains helps transform him into the hero by the end of the novel (he needs the ring to gain that status) o We don’t get a discussion about the negative ramifications of the ring in The Hobbit.